The review was written by Tim
October 2005

Well it was time for new shoes and I wanted to try something new.  So, I went with the Highlines.  While fitting them in the store I was impressed with the sock-like tongue.  It seemed to add a slight bit more cushion and comfort around the foot.  I had read many positive reviews of the Montrail trail running shoes and was eager to get them on the trail.  My first time out in them the fit was great and they weren't too warm in the Summer heat of Texas. The sock-like tongue was great; it didn't put any added pressure points on the foot and seemed to add a great deal of protection.  Most noticeable in this shoe was the feel of great cushioning in the forefoot and heel.  Protection from rocks intruding into the footbed was adequate in all areas except the arch.  The Highline also provided great protection on the outside of the toebox for that occasional toe stubbing exercise.  After this first trail run I was happy with the Highlines.  On my next run some weaknesses were exposed.  I found that the outsole did not provide a confident feel while running over slick rocks or running downhill on dry rocky(gravelly) terrain.

Pros: Sock-like tongue. Cushioning feel.

Cons: Outsole not aggressive enough.  Lack of protection in arch.

My Highlines are now nearing the end of their use on the trail and I can say they have been a solid performer.  They continued to provide good cushion on all of my runs and given a more aggressive outsole I would definitely look at them when shopping for new trail runners.